Mario's

Discover delicious, affordable dining at Mario's Pizza in Oriskany Falls, NY. Enjoy flavorful wings, calzones, subs, fish fry, and more. Call +1 315-821-7288 for delicious homemade favorites!

Welcome to Mario's

Experience the finest dining

Mario's
Mario's
Mario's
Mario's

Mario's Pizza Restaurant, located at 184 Main St in Oriskany Falls, NY, invites food lovers to indulge in a cozy dining experience. Known for its extensive menu, Mario's caters to a variety of tastes with its wide range of pizzas, calzones, wings, and more. Locals especially appreciate the flavorful dishes at affordable prices. The vibrant atmosphere buzzes with excitement, particularly on Friday nights when the dining room fills up quickly. Every dish from the garlic knots to the spicy pepperoni rolls boasts a commitment to quality and flavor, making it a beloved spot for families and friends alike. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely meal, Mario's delivers a satisfying culinary experience that keeps customers coming back.

Mario's takes pride in a menu that's as diverse as its community. Offering over 70 items, guests can choose from scrumptious salads, hearty subs, and piping hot pizzas. Signature dishes like the Chicken Riggie Pizza and Fish Fry stand out, showing off the culinary talent within. Mario's also appeals to those craving something hearty, with delicious calzones and exceptional garlic knots that make the perfect side. The restaurant's relaxed vibe encourages friendly conversations, making it an ideal spot to catch up with neighbors or celebrate special occasions.

Don't miss out on unique weekly specials or juicy wings that locals rave about. Frequent visitors often share tales of their personal favorites, creating a dynamic atmosphere filled with camaraderie.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

184 Main St, Oriskany Falls, NY 13425, United States

Phone

+1 315-821-7288

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Mario's
Mario's
Mario's
Mario's

Mario's Pizza Restaurant has carved out a niche in Oriskany Falls, becoming synonymous with delicious Italian-American comfort food. Locals know it as a gathering place for food lovers who crave a homey atmosphere blended with delightful cuisine. The restaurant offers a vast menu that features everything from stuffed calzones loaded with cheese to crispy fried shrimp dinners, highlighting the kitchen's dedication to variety. Additionally, the adventurous eaters can try unique pizzas like the BLT Pizza or the Chicken Riggie Pizza, which showcase local flavors. Mario's also excels with its wraps and rich salads, accommodating every taste preference and dietary need.

The history of Mario's intertwines with the story of the community, as it welcomes customers not just for meals, but for meaningful connections. Whether it's date night or dinner with the kids, every visit feels special, turning meals into lasting memories. Frequent diners often recall moments spent sampling the famed turkey sub or enjoying a Friday special with friends.

With Mario's commitment to satisfying palates at reasonable prices, it thrives on the support of its loyal customer base. The staff, known for their friendly service, often cheerfully engages with guests, remembering regular orders and personalizing each experience. This creates a sense of belonging rarely found in larger chain restaurants. Inside, Mario's boasts a warm ambiance filled with the enticing scents of freshly baked dough and simmering sauces, inviting passersby to experience the allure of authentic Italian cuisine.

As a staple in Oriskany Falls, Mario's exemplifies the spirit of community dining. Newcomers are often greeted with a comforting smile, while locals share their cherished dishes, encouraged by the unforgettable flavors that define this beloved eatery. It's a place where food, friendship, and flavors come together.

Mario's

The exterior of Mario's Pizza Restaurant exudes charm with its inviting signage and warm brick facade, making it hard to resist stepping inside. Nestled along the main street, this cozy spot stands out amidst the bustle of Oriskany Falls. Outdoor seating options enhance the dining experience during warmer months, allowing guests to soak in the ambiance and local flair. The friendly atmosphere invites patrons to relax and enjoy their time, whether they are dining alone or gathering with family. As locals often say, ‘Mario's feels like home,’ and that warm, welcoming vibe greets everyone who walks through the door.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday12-5 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Mario's Pizzeria is the standard. Best pizza shop I've ever been to in my life. Simply & respectfully!

D
DeeRok

I have loved pizza my entire life but most places don't come close to this Mario's Pizzeria in small Oriskany Falls, NY. The garlic knots are amazing, the everything wings, crisper to perfection and ham topped pizza. All made with love and devotion. The result is something so delicious it is hard to find anywhere else other than in the middle of nowhere, Upstate New York. I haven't had pizza in four months and this was my amazing reward to waiting. I have been coming here for over 30 years. My family, no matter where they are always ask me when I am going next. They long for Mario's as I do every time I have been away for awhile. Tonight my brother was in town from Denver and all we could talk about was going to Mario's. We had this meal to carry on the traditions we had with our parents and grandparents. We enjoyed it as I know they would want us to. Mario, the owner has become close to my family over the years and it makes the meal special every time. It's not going to a pizza place, it's like going to a family member's kitchen for a special dinner. I can't wait to have it again soon.

D
Derek S.

I was recommended this place when I came into town by a client. I'm from Texas but have a soft spot, read craving, for a NY Slice. Always. The spot it self was cool. The staff were very nice and the pizza. Oh man. The pizza. Crispy, cheesy, good topping distribution, pepperoni not to greasy. The dough was superb. The kind of crust you enjoy as much as the pie. I may never make it to this part of NY again. But if I do. I'll be stopping back by here.

C
Colin R.

Best pepperoni rolls ever! Delicious pizza as well. Incredible friendly staff! Always a fun stop. Highly recommend!

S
Stephanie C.

Never had an issue always good quality food and friendly service

A
Amy F.

Nice little place. I often eat out when on the road, most of the time the food sucks. Not this time. The salad reminded me of the salad I had at a Italian restaurant in Germany, when I was their last. The food was Great. Hopefully, I'll be back.

H
Hans H.